Storage Tips for First-Time Renters

If you’re renting a self storage unit for the first time, you’re not alone. More than one in ten Americans currently rent storage, whether they’re downsizing, renovating, moving, or just running out of space at home. But finding the right unit and preparing for move-in can feel overwhelming the first time around.

This guide walks you through everything you need to know before renting your first storage unit—from choosing the right size and type to packing, securing, and maintaining your belongings safely. Whether you’re storing for a few months or several years, these first time storage renter tips will help you save time, money, and stress.

1. Understand Why You Need Storage

Before you rent a unit, take a moment to clarify your purpose. Are you storing temporarily during a move or renovation, or will this be long-term storage for seasonal items or business inventory?

Your storage needs will guide every decision that follows, including:



• Size: A short-term move might need a larger unit for furniture and boxes, while long-term storage can often fit in a smaller space once items are organized vertically.
• Type: Climate control, drive-up access, or indoor units may all serve different goals.
• Location: Choosing a nearby facility can save time and fuel if you’ll visit your unit often.

To find the perfect match, start by browsing our Goodfellas Storage locations across the Carolinas and beyond.

2. Pick the Right Unit Size

Choosing the wrong size is one of the most common mistakes first-time renters make. Too small, and you’ll end up frustrated trying to cram things in. Too large, and you’ll overpay each month for unused space.

Our storage unit size guide makes it easy to visualize what fits in each unit. As a quick reference:

• 5x10: Great for small apartments, college dorms, or a few pieces of furniture and boxes.
• 10x10: Fits the contents of a one-bedroom apartment, including appliances and living room furniture.
• 10x15: Ideal for a small home or business inventory.
• 10x20+: Perfect for multi-bedroom homes, larger vehicles, or business storage.

Tip: When in doubt, go one size larger. It allows for easier movement inside your unit and room to add future items.

3. Drive-Up vs. Indoor Storage

Understanding your access options can make storage more convenient.

• Drive-Up Storage Units: Like having your own personal garage, drive-up units let you park directly in front for easy loading and unloading. They’re ideal for furniture, tools, and equipment.
• Indoor Units: These units offer added protection from weather and pests, often located inside multi-unit buildings. They’re ideal for documents, electronics, and household goods.

If you’re storing delicate or temperature-sensitive items such as artwork, electronics, or wooden furniture, consider a climate-controlled unit (available at select Goodfellas Storage locations like Manning, SC).

4. Pack and Label Like a Pro

A great storage experience starts with how you pack. The key to preventing damage and staying organized is preparation.

Here are some pro-level packing strategies inspired by our post Top Packing Hacks for Long-Term Storage:

• Use uniform boxes. Stack neatly and efficiently using boxes of similar size and strength.
• Label every side. Write contents and room names on at least two sides of each box.
• Avoid plastic bags. They trap moisture and can cause mold or mildew.
• Disassemble large furniture. Keep hardware in labeled bags and tape them to the furniture.
• Use shelves or pallets. Keeping items slightly off the floor protects them from dust or minor water exposure.

5. Protect Your Belongings with the Right Coverage

Even with a secure facility, tenant protection plans are essential. Fires, floods, and other unforeseen events can happen anywhere.

At Goodfellas Storage, we offer affordable tenant protection plans designed specifically for storage renters. These plans go beyond typical homeowners or renters insurance, covering the full replacement cost of your stored items in case of damage or theft.

Quick Tip: Always confirm coverage limits and exclusions before move-in day. It’s a small step that can prevent major headaches later.

6. Maximize Space Inside Your Unit

Making the most of your storage space saves money and keeps your items easy to access.

Take a cue from our guide Storage Unit Hacks Every Homeowner Should Know:

• Stack heavier boxes at the bottom. This prevents crushing fragile items.
• Create aisles. Leave a small walkway down the center so you can reach items in the back.
• Use vertical space. Stand mattresses upright, stack chairs seat-to-seat, and store long items vertically.
• Add shelving units. Freestanding metal shelves make it easy to organize boxes, tools, and décor.

A well-planned layout will make future visits faster and easier.

7. Know What You Can and Can’t Store

All storage facilities have restrictions to ensure safety and compliance. Typical prohibited items include:

• Flammable materials (gasoline, paint, propane tanks)
• Food or perishables
• Live animals or plants
• Firearms and ammunition
• Hazardous chemicals

If you’re unsure, ask your facility manager before storing. It’s better to confirm than risk a violation or damage to your belongings.

8. Plan for Accessibility

Think about how often you’ll need to access your storage unit.

• Short-term renters (during a move or renovation) may only need occasional visits, so convenience and access hours matter less.
• Long-term renters might need regular access, so choose a location close to home or work with extended gate hours.

Most Goodfellas Storage facilities offer secure, gated access and wide driveways for easy loading and unloading.

9. Keep It Organized Over Time

Organization shouldn’t end once you move in. Maintaining your unit saves time and frustration down the road.

Every few months:

• Revisit your inventory and remove items you no longer need.
• Sweep or dust your unit to prevent buildup.
• Check for moisture or pests, especially in long-term storage.

Staying organized also makes it easier to rotate seasonal items such as holiday décor, outdoor gear, and clothing.

10. Use Storage During Home Projects and Transitions

Self storage is perfect for more than just moving. It’s a flexible solution for everyday life events like:

• Home renovations (store furniture and electronics safely off-site)
• Downsizing or decluttering (see Decluttering a Garage? Here’s When to Use a Storage Unit)
• Staging a home for sale
• College or military transitions
• Small business inventory management

With affordable monthly rates and flexible terms, storage can help simplify your life without committing to a bigger home or office.

11. Security and Peace of Mind

When you store your belongings, you’re trusting a facility to protect what matters most. Look for security features such as:

• Fenced and gated property
• 24/7 surveillance cameras
• Individual unit locks
• Bright lighting and clean surroundings

Goodfellas Storage takes security seriously. All of our properties are fenced and gated (except Summerton, SC, which offers open, convenient access for local customers) and equipped with modern surveillance.

12. Common Mistakes to Avoid as a First-Time Renter

Avoid these pitfalls to make your first storage experience smooth and stress-free:

• Waiting until the last minute to reserve your unit (popular sizes fill quickly)
• Skipping insurance coverage
• Packing items haphazardly without labeling or protecting fragile goods
• Storing prohibited materials that could risk damage or penalties
• Forgetting to pay attention to access hours or climate needs

Preparation is everything. Spending an extra hour planning today can save you hours of frustration later.

13. How to Get Started

Ready to rent your first storage unit? Here’s how to begin:

1. Find your nearest Goodfellas Storage location. Browse our locations page to view available units and prices.
2. Use the size guide to determine the right fit for your belongings.
3. Add tenant protection for extra peace of mind.
4. Reserve online or by phone—it takes only a few minutes to secure your unit.

Final Thoughts

Your first storage rental doesn’t have to be complicated. With a little planning, clear labeling, and a secure facility, self storage can be an easy, cost-effective way to keep your home clutter-free and your possessions safe.

Whether you’re decluttering, downsizing, or in between moves, Goodfellas Storage is here to help you every step of the way. Explore our locations to get started today and enjoy the confidence that comes with storing smart.